Skip to content

Philly School District should follow Penn Alexander method

Blue-Ribbon school’s techniques should be used throughout system

SINCE IT opened in 2001, the Penn Alexander Elementary School in West Philadelphia has gained a reputation as a diverse, high-performing school so popular with parents in the neighborhood that demand for spaces exceeds the supply.

Now, that reputation has been confirmed by the U.S. government. Last week, U.S. Secretary of Education John King awarded Penn Alexander with a 2016 National Blue Ribbon for excellence.

The prestigious award was given to nine other schools in the region as well, including two in Philadelphia: the FACTS Charter School at 10th and Callowhill streets, and St. Mary's Interparochial, a Catholic grade school in Society Hill.

All of the winners-there were 329 nationwide-were cited by King as "shining examples" of how education can and should work.

Can Penn Alexander serve as an example in the Philadelphia School District that can be repeated in other schools? The short answer is no.

Penn Alexander has a special relationship with the University of Pennsylvania, which uses it in part as an on-site laboratory for its graduate students in education. Penn also chips in an additional $1,330 a year for each of the school's 550 students.

That additional money gives Penn Alexander a leg up over other schools in the system that the District is in no position to match. Still, it might be able to copy the learning environment created at Penn Alexander, one that includes an excellent principal, flexibility in selection of staff and a rigorous academic curriculum.

Part of the credit should go to the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, which allowed Penn Alexander to be what is called a "demonstration school," exempt from certain contract provisions (though not those that involve wage and benefits). For one thing, the school does not fill vacancies by using the seniority system.

It requires teaching applicants to take a written test and to spend time in a classroom under the eye of the principal and others. If a teacher does not work out, it also has an expedited review process.

Given Penn Alexander's success, why aren't these techniques used in the rest of the district? The answer is the union's contract. The PFT allowed Penn Alexander to be an exception, not the rule. It is against so-called "site selection" that doesn't take into account teacher seniority.

Superintendent William Hite did institute site selection in the district several years ago, arguing that since the union's contract had expired, the rules on teacher selection no longer applied. The union has filed a grievance against Hite's actions, which is wending its way through the system.

There may be an opportunity to change this situation. The union has gone without a new contract for about four years now, essentially playing rope-a-dope in the hope political conditions will change to make Hite's demands about site selection, seniority and other word rules go away.

The downside is that the union's members haven't received any pay increase for four years. We believe the time has come for the two sides to sit down and work out an agreement that gives Hite the flexibility he wants and teachers the raises they deserve.

To its credit, the PFT allowed Penn Alexander to be an exception. Given its success, it may be time to make the Penn Alexander method the rule.