Phila. needs creative solution to funding crises
Philadelphia's political leaders have important and far-ranging choices to make in the weeks ahead. To their credit, our elected officials have proposed a range of initiatives to address several enormous challenges. What is required now is that the linkage of these challenges be understood and accepted, that personal relationships and strains among leaders be put aside, and that the art of compromise - the good part of politics - be practiced.
Philadelphia's political leaders have important and far-ranging choices to make in the weeks ahead. To their credit, our elected officials have proposed a range of initiatives to address several enormous challenges. What is required now is that the linkage of these challenges be understood and accepted, that personal relationships and strains among leaders be put aside, and that the art of compromise - the good part of politics - be practiced.
The three linked stresses are school funding, the unsustainable pension system, and the 21st-century role of city government. Let me explain.
Several years ago, the commonwealth granted the city the right to an additional 1 percent sales tax to help relieve the municipal pension fund crisis. That temporary tax had a five-year life and was enacted to assist the city to chip away at its huge unfunded pension liability, now $5 billion. Despite the infusion of this new funding, the crisis remains. The system is only 47.4 percent funded, signaling, if untended, major looming trouble for retired and retiring municipal employees.
Last year, the commonwealth granted an extension of the 1 percent sales tax to fund a school system that is a fiscally bankrupt enterprise, as subtly evidenced by the unwillingness of the School Reform Commission to even approve a new budget. Restoration of state support for education remains a critical but elusive objective. But this dedicated revenue stream moved our community away from unsustainable annual fixes for funding public education to acceptance that the city would have to assume a greater obligation for fiscal support of schools.
City Council's proposal to split the proceeds of the 1 percent sales tax between school and pension funding is a clear indication that both crises now share priority standing. Council President Darrell L. Clarke should be commended for this leadership. But his argument that the best option is to split the sales-tax revenue between schools and pensions ignores other policy choices on the table. And this is not about fiscal stability versus political expediency.
The immediate opportunity comes from the private offer to purchase the Philadelphia Gas Works, a transaction that took courage to pursue and successfully position. Kudos to Mayor Nutter, PGW, and their team.
In approving the sale of PGW and dedicating the first $120 million of the sales tax to our schools, the city can tackle both problems and send a powerful message to skeptical state leaders that Philadelphia is innovatively addressing challenges with smart policy choices.
The price offered to the city to acquire PGW is simply an offer we can't and shouldn't refuse. A $1.8 billion sale price is, by any standard, "rich." Those who suggest that we've fixed PGW, and therefore shouldn't sell it, are forgetting the long, troubled history of a municipal utility with a track record for uneven performance whose value when distressed could never fetch a price comparable to the current offer.
If the city sells PGW, Philadelphians will still be able to get gas. Among the 10 largest American cities, only ours owns a gas company. Gas is simply not an essential municipal service, like public safety. The answer to the question of whether this sale transaction is a good one for the city and its gas customers is resoundingly yes! Strained mayoral-Council relations need to be subordinated to the interests of the city to get this deal done.
For Philadelphia, PGW sale proceeds should be maximized and dedicated to reducing pension-fund deficits. On an annualized basis, the investment income from the sale proceeds will help increase support for the mandated municipal contributions to the pension system. Growing the ratio of pension-fund assets to liabilities to 80 percent is an important goal around which a consensus seems to have formed. Pledging 50 percent of the sales tax toward this goal projects to get us there by 2026, but would leave the schools in a permanent financial quagmire. But using the amounts of collected sales taxes in excess of $120 million, together with the PGW sale proceeds, will enable the pension fund to achieve this 80 percent goal by 2028. This is a compromise Philadelphia can live with.
By linking the sales-tax extension with the sale of PGW, our leaders can show a capacity for compromise, send a message to Harrisburg that we are truly a city of the first class, start a conversation about what a restructured 21st-century city government might look like, and make a partial but important municipal commitment to providing reliable public school funding.
Taken together, these actions would provide a lasting legacy for the Nutter administration and City Council. Now is the time to get them both done.
























