
Rules of war
An Associated Press article on Nov. 13 reported that Israel carried out an airstrike on the grounds of the Nasser Hospital in Gaza, targeting Muhammad Abu Ismail, a prominent Hamas terrorist leader. It’s tragic that Hamas has commandeered Gaza hospitals and used them as terror bases. As the article noted, “Hamas security men have sometimes been seen in hospitals, controlling access to certain areas.”
Israel has sufficient military power to level every hospital in Gaza if it wants. The fact that it has not done so illustrates its efforts to avoid civilian sites whenever possible during its counterterrorist operations.
The Allies sometimes faced similar issues during World War II. Recall the case of the hospital facilities in Rabaul, in Japanese-occupied New Guinea. The Japanese government in June 1944 accused the U.S. of knowingly bombing those sites, in contravention of international laws prohibiting military action against hospitals.
The Roosevelt administration replied that the U.S. airstrikes were justified because the Japanese had positioned “concentrations of heavy, automatic and machine gun anti-aircraft weapons” among the hospital buildings, deliberately setting up the weapons “in close proximity” to medical facilities that “were marked with red crosses.” Therefore, the administration said, it was the Japanese who had turned the area into one of “legitimate military targets,” and therefore it was they who bore “all responsibility” for damage caused to the hospitals.
Rafael Medoff, director, The David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, Washington, D.C.
AIPAC influence
In Rep. Thomas R. Suozzi’s recent guest essay, he argued that “antisemitism has no place in the City of Brotherly Love.” Suozzi failed to mention in his column that he has received hundreds of thousands of dollars in contributions from the pro-Israeli lobby, including AIPAC. He also forgot to mention that he has repeatedly voted to support massive funding for the Israeli military.
Israel has a population of about 10 million. Yet, Israel has the fourth most powerful military in the world. This means the Israeli government needs massive amounts of money to sustain its military. It needed even more money to carry out its genocidal campaign against Palestinians over the past three years. It also needs money to carry out wars against Lebanon, Syria, and Iran. The United States has increased funding to Israel from $3.8 billion to about $20 billion. What was the result of this aid?
The so-called Israel Defense Forces murdered more than 70,000 Palestinians. Half of those murdered were children. Yet Rep. Suozzi argues that people who protest this unimaginable horror are “antisemitic.”
I happen to be Jewish. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu argues that the genocide he is organizing against Palestinians serves the interests of all Jews, including me. When we consider the unimaginable horror that is being organized by the Israeli government today, I believe we need to draw another conclusion.
Instead of organizing to murder people throughout the Middle East, the Israeli government needs to recognize that all Palestinians need to have the same rights as Jewish people living in Israel. That isn’t antisemitism. That is the only way there will ever be peace in the Middle East.
Steven Halpern, Philadelphia
About letters to the editor
Letters feature a reader’s written opinion and are submitted in response to an article in The Inquirer or another topical issue. Submissions should be sent to letters@inquirer.com. Limit length to 150 words and include the writer’s home address and day and evening phone number. Letters are published in the Inquirer six days a week on the print opinion pages and online.
























