Skip to content

DN Editorial: College requirement nice, but we need more cops & diversity

WE DON'T like the idea of lowering the educational requirements for Philadelphia police applicants, but we sympathize with dilemma Commissioner Richard Ross faces.

WE DON'T like the idea of lowering the educational requirements for Philadelphia police applicants, but we sympathize with dilemma Commissioner Richard Ross faces.

The complement of filled positions in the department is the lowest in 22 years, Ross told City Council this week. The department is budgeted to have 6,525 uniformed officers. It currently has 6,100.

That's too big a hole, considering the vital role the police play in our communities. Fewer feet on the street surely can only mean more crime.

Prior to the arrival of Commissioner Charles Ramsey, an applicant only needed a high school diploma or a GED. Ramsey sought to raise the educational level of the force by requiring applicants to have 60 college credits, the equivalent of an associate's degree.

But, competition among police departments is stiff on both a local and national level. The pool of applicants has shrunk. And Philadelphia police are having a hard time finding new recruits.

That has led Ross to change the policy back to requiring only a high school diploma, but increasing the age that one can apply from 19 to 22. The thinking there is that by raising the age, the department will attract applicants who have more life experience. Most of them will have been out of high school for five years and had jobs to give them the work discipline they need.

Also, training at the Police Academy is the equivalent of a year of advanced schooling - cadets attend for 10 months before graduating to the streets. Rookies are paid $47,500 a year, but usually have the opportunity to make more with overtime, and the base salary increases over time.

The average salary for all 4,800 patrol officers is $66,393.

The police have taken a number of steps in recent years to increase the pool of applicants. For instance, it used to be a requirement that a person be a city resident for at least one year before being allowed to apply. Now, there is no residency requirement for applicants, although they are encouraged to move into the city within six months after graduation.

There are a number of hurdles applicants must clear before they are accepted: a reading comprehension test, a physical-agility test and psychological testing. So, it is not a "come one, come all" approach to finding new police officers.

One problem with a smaller pool of applicants is that it becomes harder to find minority men and women in general who qualify. The department currently does not reflect the racial/ethnic and gender diversity of the city. Fifty-five percent of patrol officers are white; 35 percent black, while the gender split is 76 percent male and 24 percent female.

Those numbers decline the higher up you go in rank. For instance, 82 percent of police captains are white and 97 percent of them are male.

Now that Commissioner Ross has changed the rules for applying, we hope it includes bona-fide efforts at minority and female recruitment. It's not just a matter of fairness, it is also common sense: In a city with increasing number of Asians and Latinos having more Asian and Latino police officers makes for better community relations and that, in turn, helps alleviate the "us vs. them" attitude in neighborhoods about police.

If we had our druthers, we would rather the department keep is 60-credit hour requirement, but if the changes being implemented by Ross lead to more people applying and, in turn, a more diverse police force, it will be worth it.