Skip to content

Letters to the Editor

Rick Santorum's diatribe on health care ("Health reform fog is lifting," Wednesday) was no surprise. It fits in with the deluge of ongoing tea-party and Republican criticisms of health-care reform. But if you consult Factcheck, Snopes, or other reliable truth-checking sites, guess who's telling most of the whoppers? It's not President Obama and fellow Democrats.

Easy to see who's telling fibs

Rick Santorum's diatribe on health care ("Health reform fog is lifting," Wednesday) was no surprise. It fits in with the deluge of ongoing tea-party and Republican criticisms of health-care reform. But if you consult Factcheck, Snopes, or other reliable truth-checking sites, guess who's telling most of the whoppers? It's not President Obama and fellow Democrats.

To highlight a few oft-repeated false claims: There was no government takeover. It's not socialized medicine. The government won't be choosing your doctor. There are no death panels, no rationing, no direct public funding of abortion services, and no funding for illegal immigrants. Nor does Obamacare add a trillion dollars to the deficit.

There never was a promise that health care would immediately cost less. Only that the rate of increase would slowly decline over time, and that the cost would be much greater if we did nothing. But don't worry, the truth will eventually emerge, just as it did with false claims about Iraq's supposed WMD.

Jim Bibber

Upper Darby

jbibbersr@msn.com

nolead begins

Emphasis on power spurs violent crime

Re: "Man, 18, charged in waitress' slaying," Thursday:

Sabina Rose O'Donnell's recent rape and murder is a tragedy. I am dismayed that the Philadelphia police and you are framing this crime as a robbery that escalated. The suspect was clearly physically stronger than O'Donnell, so why didn't he just take her bike and leave? Instead, he dragged O'Donnell behind a building, ripped off her clothes, raped her, and strangled her. He then left her bike behind the building in order to try breaking into other apartments in her building.

Our society teaches young people the way to get what you want and feel powerful is through violence (including sexual violence). We preach the gospel of power over instead of power with. This plays out in our intimate relationships (a fourth of U.S. women are victims of intimate partner violence), our communities, (O'Donnell's death), and our world.

Susanna Gilbertson

Philadelphia

nolead begins

No tears needed for the coal industry

George Ellis' critique of renewable energy's job-creation potential doesn't make sense ("Don't believe the 'green jobs' hype," June 15).

Already, Pennsylvania ranks fifth nationally in wind-energy supply-chain employment, with 4,000 citizens manufacturing wind turbines and components. The Department of Environmental Protection reports 350,000 residents are working in renewable-related industries.

Ellis says the state's coal industry is responsible for 41,500 jobs. All of these jobs are crucial to local energy independence; we should work to keep and grow them all, not sacrifice one for the other.

If government shouldn't pick energy-sector winners and losers via subsidies, as Ellis contends, then it's difficult to explain why U.S. fossil-fuel industries received $72 billion in subsidies from 2002 through 2008, according to the Environmental Law Institute, while renewable-energy subsidies reached only $29 billion during that same period.

Instead of asking Pennsylvanians to choose among a smokestack, coal mine, or wind turbine, let's make collaboration, not confrontation, cutting-edge for the commonwealth.

Michael Peck

Director of external affairs

Gamesa North America

Langhorne

nolead begins

After Gulf spill, must make changes

Based on your editorial Wednesday, "BP must pay," you must agree with President Obama that it is adequate to merely assign blame and who will pay for the Gulf oil spill. No economic settlement will ever compensate for this ecological disaster. It took 20 years to fully settle the Exxon Valdez claims. Many died before receiving a settlement.

What is unconscionable is that our country has no means to avert or deal with another disaster like this, even though we have 4,000 oil wells in harm's way out in the Gulf.

If this administration were serious about weaning America off of oil, the newly announced fuel-efficiency standards for the truck/SUV category would be higher.

John L. Waring

Mount Laurel

nolead begins

Charter approach isn't a panacea

Our country's public education system is broken. With only 55 percent of Philadelphia's public-school students graduating from high school, accusations fly about who is to blame.

While bad policy and lack of resources often hinder a teacher's creativity, successful teachers don't make excuses for their students. And although KIPP is a phenomenal model ("Charters' approach is working," Wednesday), its teachers' long hours and demanding schedule make it an unsustainable large-scale model.

What is most worrisome is the lack of focus, on both sides, about the point of public education. Are we trying to achieve a healthy democracy or a strong workforce? And why do we see these goals as mutually exclusive? A strong public education system is needed for a strong democracy.

People need to believe in public education again. We're all trying to save the education system, so there is not going to be one right or wrong solution. However, it is going to take a lot of creativity and cooperation to help our students and our country get back on track.

Maggie Roth

Berwyn

Letters to the Editor

Chat live about Chief Justice Ron Castille and the Family Court investigation Monday at 1 p.m. at www.philly.com.

EndText