Skip to content

Flawed 'child protection'

ACCORDING to G.K. Chesterton, "The reformer is always right about what is wrong. He is generally wrong about what is right."

ACCORDING to G.K. Chesterton, "The reformer is always right about what is wrong. He is generally wrong about what is right."

Reformers may be ahead of the curve in identifying a wrong yet be ill-equipped to make it right.

Unfortunately, the unintended consequences of good intentions are rarely inconsequential. Pennsylvania's Child Protective Services Law is a textbook example of good intentions gone awry.

Because juvenile-court proceedings are closed to the public, my role as a parents' attorney in Chester County's Juvenile Dependency Court provides the opportunity few have: to witness the injustices wrought on families by the good intentions of the law.

The Child Protective Services Law is one of three Pennsylvania statutes that permits state intervention in child-abuse and dependency cases. Its aim is to protect children from serious physical or mental injury, sexual abuse or sexual exploitation, and serious physical neglect.

Primarily a reporting statute, CPSL was enacted to encourage more-complete reporting of child abuse, provide swift delivery of protective services to prevent further abuse and stabilize families.

A report of suspected child abuse to the state Department of Public Welfare's Child Line triggers an investigation by the county protective agency (in Chester County, the Department of Children, Youth and Families).

So, mission accomplished, right?

Well - not quite.

In theory, the law achieves its purpose. In practice, it overreaches in two important respects. First, it mandates that teachers and those who in the course of employment, occupation or practice come into contact with children report suspected child abuse to authorities. Failure to do so is a crime. Second, it confers protective agencies with quasi-police and -judicial powers to investigate those reports. Together, these provisions prove the adage that two wrongs don't make a right.

Mandating reporting raises several concerns. First, it compels teachers and others to become agents of the state. Next, the threat of criminal prosecution effectively ensures a constant flow of reports to be investigated as mandated reporters cover their butts by reporting every bruise, scratch and accusation.

Finally, this responsibility injects an element of suspicion and duplicity into the relationship between (generally lower-income or minority) parents and those in loco parentis, and radically alters the balance of power in the neverending tug-of-war between children for autonomy and parents for control.

Worse, subsequent investigations are woefully inadequate to protect the innocent. A "child-protective investigation" ends in one of three ways: a "founded" report in which there has been any adjudication that a child has been abused, including the entry of a plea of guilty or a finding of guilt to criminal child abuse; an "indicated" report in which investigators determine that there is "substantial evidence of child abuse," or all other "unfounded" reports.

The effects of "founded" and " indicated" abuse are virtually identical. The perpetrator (again, usually lower-income and/or minority) is listed on the statewide central register of child abusers and barred from many activities and occupations. Often, the child is removed from the home.

An investigation that results in "indicated" abuse is the polar opposite of "founded" abuse. With the latter, the suspect at a minimum has a right to counsel and a hearing. The subject of the former is not as lucky.

ASTONISHINGLY, the law authorizes county social workers to act as judge, jury and prosecutors in cases of "indicated" abuse. Untrained in the law and acting without judicial restraint, review or oversight, they render judgments that demand (but which the CPSL utterly fails to provide), the ultimate in fair play, due process and fundamental justice.

Every parent should be alarmed at this frightening prospect because mandated reporting and child-protective services investigations put every parent's reputation, livelihood and parental rights in jeopardy.

The CPSL may be right about what is wrong, but in several respects is frightfully wrong about what is right.

Gerald K. McOscar, a lawyer, lives in West Chester.