Skip to content

Cash for trash?

ON THURSDAY, Mayor Nutter will tell us how the city plans to balance its budget in the face of an economy that hasn't improved much since last year, leaving a deficit that could be as high as $150 million.

ON THURSDAY, Mayor Nutter will tell us how the city plans to balance its budget in the face of an economy that hasn't improved much since last year, leaving a deficit that could be as high as $150 million.

One of the big questions of the day: Will the city impose a trash fee to help close the gap?

The administration ran that idea up the flagpole least year, and found it had to wheel it back down rather quickly. But with limited options - and more limited appetite - for increasing taxes or other revenues this year, it seems likely this will be back on the table.

If so, we expect the fee to be met with another question, this from taxpayers: What the hell do we pay taxes for anyway, if we can't even get trash pickup for free?

Our instinctual response is to agree, at least to the question. And while there are a host of logistical questions to answer on such a fee, we think it's a good time to address the more philosophical question that such a fee suggests: What the hell do we pay our taxes for?

The actual answer may surprise many Philadelphians. Because the actual answer is that our taxes go to pay for pensions and health benefits of city employees, prisons, debt service and social services. In that order. Those are the largest categories of city expenditures.

That means that average working taxpayers in the city pay for things that they'll never see or services they never use. That's not just a fact, but it's a truth of the city and its budget challenges that we all need to grasp. (For a detailed look at the budget, access the Citizen's Guide at www.picapa.org.)

One of the driving challenges for the city budget is the high cost of pensions and health benefits for city workers. Keeping that workforce small is one way to gain control over these costs. But it's also one way to guarantee fewer services; it means, for example, that fewer police and firefighters get to keep their jobs.

But an even bigger factor in the city's budget is our high poverty rate. In this city, nearly 20 percent of families fall below the poverty line. That means high expenditures for human services. But it also means that by nature of their low salaries or lack of employment, a huge segment of the city contributes little to the city coffers. The city derives half of its tax revenue from the wage tax (the real-estate, business and sales taxes are the next three big categories). Those revenues have taken a hit, and high unemployment will rob the city's coffers.

If wage earners, businesses and property owners carry more than their fair share of the burdens of the city budget, shouldn't they get their trash picked up as a result? What is reasonable to expect from our taxes?

That's the real discussion that the trash-fee idea should generate. Are our taxes simply the price of admission to live in a large diverse city, with services increasingly on a pay-as-you-use basis? If the trash-fee idea fails, what other services are citizens willing to give up instead?

Whatever the particulars of his budget address, we hope that the mayor uses this year's budget as a way of addressing some of these bigger questions. Balancing the budget is only part of his job. The other part is helping taxpayers understand how much they can expect their taxes to pay for their own services, and how much they should pay for someone else's. *