Why not elect the school board?
PHILADELPHIANS should elect the people who run their schools. Recently, this simple democratic ideal has gained traction and support from Tom Wolf, newly elected governor, and since then there has been a chorus of anti-democratic op-eds, most recently from former District CEO Phil Goldsmith ("dumb idea") a
PHILADELPHIANS should elect the people who run their schools.
Recently, this simple democratic ideal has gained traction and support from Tom Wolf, newly elected governor, and since then there has been a chorus of anti-democratic op-eds, most recently from former District CEO Phil Goldsmith ("dumb idea") and veteran reporter Dave Davies ("bad idea"). The substance of both these editorials is that we are better off with a school board chosen by the city's elites rather than entrusting decisions to the electorate, because in an election the choices will be made by party bosses and union leaders.
As many have pointed out, the implications of this position, if drawn to its logical conclusion, is that we would be better off without an elected City Council and elected state representatives, because these elections would be shaped by the Democratic Party organization and influenced by unions, among others. Even if we grant that the political process as it currently functions is seriously flawed, there are numerous problems with this anti-democratic argument.
To begin with, this is a static view of the city's political life, which assumes that mass movements - like the one that has developed around our schools - cannot alter the local electoral landscape. This position is contradicted by our history. In the late '70s an independent black political movement defeated machine-backed candidates and elected candidates. And during the years, individual progressive candidates with ties to popular struggles have won or waged viable campaigns. These facts are buoyed by the emergence of the Working Families Party, which promises to alter the map inside the Democratic Party.
Moreover, other cities, notably New York and Pittsburgh, have seen change driven by concerns about education. In New York, education was a major factor in the election of Bill de Blasio; and in Pittsburgh, four progressives opposed to school privatization were elected to the school board.
A second problem with this argument is that the authors implicitly contrast "party bosses," who are characterized as interested only in "jobs and favors," versus appointed people who, apparently, are guided by high notions of public interest. Yes, the party organization has elements that favor corruption, nepotism and putting narrow interest ahead of the common good. At the same time, the party also includes many people who seek positions in the organization as a means to improve their community and influence political life based on the issues they care about. An upsurge in grassroots movements, like the one we are seeing around education, is bound to strengthen the hand of these progressive elements in the party organization.
Finally, does anyone really believe that appointed members are disinterested political actors? Appointees are selected based on their loyalty to those that appoint them, and frequently these actors have definite interests in matters that come before school boards, like the awarding of contracts. The difference between elected and appointed school-board members is that appointees do not go through any process where they are held accountable to voters and therefore must contend for the support of parents, education advocates and the broader community.
Both Davies and Goldsmith argue that union leaders will have undue influence with an elected board. But what about the influence of moneyed interests, like Philadelphia School Partnership, which has the inner track in the present system, and is funded by Bill Gates and the Walmart heirs? Why doesn't their undue influence disturb Davies and Goldsmith? Unions are democratic organizations that enter the electoral arena to represent the interests of their members. Without unions the electoral landscape would be less democratic and therefore more dominated by the interests of the 1 Percent.
Moreover, the education-justice movement includes young people, parents, community leaders and both faith and neighborhood-based organizations. The emerging politics of this movement link the fight for good schools with the larger struggle for economic and racial justice.
The question of how to maximize public interest and participation in school-board elections is a legitimate one, but those concerns shouldn't lead to dispensing with them. Elections, after all, are one of the main avenues open to us if we are to bring about change. The advocates for market-based education reform typically favor mayoral control while community-based education-justice forces favor more democracy and transparency.
An elected school board is not a panacea and, given the current balance of forces, it is quite possible, at least in the short-term, that it would include people we wouldn't embrace. But I'm confident we could elect some real champions of public education. Parent leaders like Helen Gym or Kia Hinton, youth advocates like Andy Perez, retired teachers like Lisa Haver. In the current system, all these leaders are cast in the role of protesters and watchdogs, but, with an elected board, they, and the movement they come out of, have a road to power.
























