Skip to content

Time to end discrimination in organ transplants in Pa.

Imagine you're a parent of a dying child in desperate need of a lung, kidney, or heart transplant and you're told by callous hospital administrators that, because of a physical infirmity or intellectual handicap, your loved one has been rejected for the life-saving surgical procedure.

Imagine you're a parent of a dying child in desperate need of a lung, kidney, or heart transplant and you're told by callous hospital administrators that, because of a physical infirmity or intellectual handicap, your loved one has been rejected for the life-saving surgical procedure.

That dreadful scenario was experienced by Karen Corby of Pottsville, when she was informed by doctors at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania that her son Paul was refused a life-saving slot on the heart-transplant list because of his intellectual disability. Paul was found to have left ventricular non-compaction five years ago. His only hope is a heart transplant.

"As if hearing the diagnosis wasn't bad enough," recalled his mother, "We then had to learn that he is not a candidate for this life-saving surgery because of his autism."

Corby was understandably devastated by this unexpected and inexplicable turn of events. She was not the first, nor would she be the last, parent to be confronted with this bit of unconscionable medical mischief.

Granted, the need for organ donors is great. More than 100,000 people in the United States are on waiting lists for an organ transplant, and healthy organs are a rare and valuable commodity. Many will die while awaiting a transplant. Rationing systems have been implemented, but subjective notions of individual worth have made it difficult to differentiate between discriminatory policies and sound clinical judgment. Instances of blatant intolerance abound.

In 1995, for example, Sandra Jensen, a 34-year old woman with Down syndrome and a terminal heart condition, was in need of a heart and lung transplant. The California State Medicaid system - her insurer - approved the procedure, but transplant hospitals turned her down. Those with Down syndrome, it was determined, were considered inappropriate for heart/lung transplants. The decision resulted in a firestorm of controversy, causing the hospital to reexamine its policy and provide Jensen with the needed transplant.

More recently and closer to home, readers may recall the brouhaha concerning Amelia Rivera, the 3-year-old New Jersey girl born with Wolf-Hirshhorn syndrome, a rare genetic disorder. Despite her need for a kidney transplant and the fact that she had a personal donor, she was denied access by Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, according to her family. Chrissy Rivera said she was told her daughter did not qualify because she was "mentally retarded."

The public outcry was immediate. Faced with a national uproar and searing news stories, CHOP apologized and approved the procedure. Amelia, now 5, has been given a new lease on life.

"She's doing great now," her mother says. "She has more energy, and she's more vocal."

Regrettably, however, there is no telling how many families of needy individuals are given unfavorable decisions that result in anguish, the premature death of a loved one, and a pronounced distrust of the medical establishment. Not every parent is willing or capable of putting up a fight with entrenched institutional powers. Karen Corby, for example, initiated an online petition drive that amassed about 300,000 signatures.

A hundred years ago, people with mental and physical disabilities were routinely referred to as morons, imbeciles, and idiots. The so-called "feeble-minded" were shunned by polite society and thrown into bleak, understaffed asylums to live out their lives as so much human refuse. Occasionally, as the recent book Against Their Will: The Secret History of Medical Experimentation on Children in Cold War America points out, such individuals were used as grist for the research mill. Such egregious acts are no longer practiced, but those with various afflictions and infirmities are still sometimes given short shrift by the medical community.

In an effort to end such discriminatory practices, House Bill 585 has been introduced in the Pennsylvania legislature. Known as "Paul's Law," the bill would:

Let programs deny transplants to people with disabilities only if the disabilities are "medically significant" to the procedure.

Bar denial to people with disabilities because they cannot comply with complex post-transplant medical regimens as long as they have an adequate support system.

California and New Jersey have passed similar legislation in recent years. Pennsylvania, as well, needs to ensure that those waiting for an organ transplant will not be discriminated against because of a mental or physical disability. They, too, deserve to be on the list and receive the same chance of receiving an organ transplant as any other deserving person.

Maureen Cronin
is executive director of the Arc of Pennsylvania
John Sabatina Jr.
is a Democratic state representative serving the 174th District

Maureen Cronin is executive director of the Arc of Pennsylvania.

John Sabatina Jr. is a Democratic state representative serving the 174th District

Contact the writers via mcronin@thearcpa.org and jsabatina@pahouse.net.